8 Tips for Managing Former Peers as a New Manager

If you’ve recently been promoted to a manager role, it can be an exciting time for your career.

However, one of the challenges you may now face is how to manage your former peers.

Managing people who were once your equals can be tricky, but with the right strategies in place, it can be done effectively.

Learn the do’s and don’ts of managing former peers to make this transition as smooth as possible.

Why is it important to manage former peers effectively?

It is important to manage former peers effectively because it helps you maintain a professional relationship and respect between yourself and those you manage. It will also help prevent any negative feelings from developing which can be detrimental to the performance of both parties.

When your team members view you as an effective leader, they are more likely to follow your instructions and work together with you to produce positive results.

How to manage former peers as a new manager

To manage former peers as a new manager it is important to set new boundaries, hold one-on-one meetings with your former peers, lead with integrity, and remember not to give preferential treatment.

1. Acknowledge the shift when managing your former peers

One of the best things you can do early on in your new role as manager is to simply acknowledge the change in the hierarchy between yourself and your former peers.

Pretending nothing will change when it comes to your professional relationships now that you’re in a management position won’t serve you or your team.

Letting your team know that you’re aware of the shift and the need for some time to transition is essential to setting a productive tone for your new relationship.

2. Be transparent when managing your former peers

Transparency is key when managing former peers.

Let your team members know what you expect from them and why, outline the responsibilities they will have in their new roles, and be open to hearing their feedback.

3. Set clear boundaries when managing your former peers

It is also important to set clear boundaries between yourself and your former peers especially if you developed friendships with any of them.

This will help maintain a sense of professionalism and respect between you both.

4. Don’t pick favorites when managing your former peers

It’s important not to show favoritism towards any of your team members, even if they were once your friends or colleagues.

Make sure everyone feels like they are treated fairly and equally, regardless of their relationship with you prior to the promotion.

5. Remind yourself you are managing your former peers

While you may have been able to vent work frustrations or joke about certain workplace policies with your former peers, it is important to remember that the dynamic has now changed.

It’s up to you to set the tone of professionalism within your team and understand that you’ll be under more scrutiny as a manager.

6. Set clear expectations when managing your former peers

Make sure to set clear expectations for your team members, such as deadlines, quality standards, and other job-related responsibilities.

This will help ensure that everyone is held accountable for their work and knows what is expected from them.

7. Lead with integrity when managing your former peers

It’s important to lead by example and maintain a high level of integrity when managing your former peers.

Show that you are committed to upholding the same standards of professionalism and respect as you did in your previous role, while also demonstrating that you are ready and willing to take on any new challenges that may arise.

8. Hold one-on-ones when managing your former peers

Finally, it’s important to regularly schedule one-on-one conversations with each individual on your team.

This will give you an opportunity to discuss their progress and development, address any concerns they may have, and ensure everyone is on the same page when it comes to meeting goals and objectives.

Common challenges faced by new managers

  • Becoming peers with former superiors as a new manager
  • Defining your day-to-day as a new manager
  • Navigating the new workload as a new manager
  • Hiring new employees as a new manager
  • Effective communication as a new manager
  • Managing difficult personalities as a new manager
  • Holding others accountable as a new manager
  • Mentoring and developing others as a new manager
  • Creating a team culture as a new manager
  • Delegating tasks effectively as a new manager
  • Prioritizing competing deadlines as a new manager
  • Resolving workplace conflicts as a new manager
  • Continuing to grow as a new manager

Some of the most common challenges faced by new managers beyond managing former peers include everything from delegating tasks effectively to hiring new employees and more.

By being aware of these common challenges, you can enter your new role as a manager armed with the confidence and strategies you need to navigate your transition with ease.

Managing your former peers

Managing your former peers as a new manager can be an intimidating process but it doesn’t have to be if you have the right awareness and strategies in place.

It’s important to communicate clear expectations, set boundaries, and uphold a sense of professionalism while also staying true to yourself and leading with integrity.

It is also important to stay open to feedback from your former peers as they may be able to provide insights or advice that can help you do your job better.

This will help set the tone for your team, create an environment of trust and respect, and ultimately ensure everyone is happy, productive in their positions, and working towards the same goals.

Looking to hire top-tier Tech, Digital Marketing, or Creative Talent? We can help.

Every year, Mondo helps to fill over 2,000 open positions nationwide.

Continued Reading on industry insights, tips, and strategies:

Related Posts

Never Miss an INsight

Subscribe to Our Blog

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

A Unique Approach to
Staffing that Works

Redefining the way clients find talent and candidates find work. 

We are technologists with the nuanced expertise to do tech, digital marketing, & creative staffing differently. We ignite our passion through our focus on our people and process. Which is the foundation of our collaborative approach that drives meaningful impact in the shortest amount of time.

Staffing tomorrow’s talent today.