What “Ban the Box” Means for Staffing Agencies & Today’s Hiring Landscape

Five adults sit side by side on stools against a plain wall, cropped from the shoulders down, holding papers or notebooks in their laps. They wear business-casual clothing and appear to be waiting, suggesting a job interview or selection process.

The Ban the Box Campaign began as a grassroots effort in the early 2000s, led by civil rights groups seeking to reduce discrimination against people with criminal records.

The movement called for the removal of the checkbox on employment applications that asks about a person’s criminal history, arguing that this practice created undue barriers to job opportunities for millions of Americans.

In today’s labor market, the movement is more relevant than ever.

With talent shortages across industries, growing emphasis on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), and expanding state and local policies, employers and staffing agencies must understand what Ban the Box means for their hiring practices.

What Is “Ban the Box”?

Ban the Box refers to the policy of removing the checkbox on a job application that asks about a candidate’s criminal convictions or conviction history. Its goal is to delay inquiries into a candidate’s criminal history until later in the hiring process, typically after a conditional offer is made.

Currently, more than 35 states and 150 cities and counties across the United States have adopted Fair Chance Laws, many of which apply to both the public and private sector.

The Fair Chance Act, passed at the federal level, ensures that federal agencies and contractors do not inquire about a candidate’s criminal offenses on the initial job application.

At its core, Ban the Box aims to promote equitable hiring by giving qualified applicants a fair shot at employment, regardless of their interactions with the criminal justice system.

Why Ban the Box Matters in the Current Job Market

Widening Talent Pools During Skill Shortages

Amid persistent talent shortages, particularly in tech and digital roles, employers need to explore all avenues to find qualified applicants.

By implementing Ban the Box policies, organizations can expand access to skilled individuals who have been historically overlooked due to their criminal records.

Many of these individuals bring unique experiences, resilience, and strong work ethics to the workplace.

Supporting Fair-Chance Hiring Initiatives

There is increasing public and corporate support for fair-chance hiring, with more employers recognizing the value of giving individuals a second chance.

These initiatives not only promote social good but also enhance employment policies and brand reputation.

Businesses that adopt Fair Chance Laws contribute to stronger communities and demonstrate alignment with modern employment law values.

Reducing Bias in Early Screening

Removing questions about criminal history from early-stage screening helps reduce employment discrimination based on past convictions.

This approach enables employers to focus on skills and experience, rather than past mistakes.

It also limits the influence of unconscious bias, particularly in AI-powered systems and automated screenings.

What Ban the Box Means for Employers

Compliance Requirements

Employers must stay informed about state and local policies that govern when and how they can inquire about a candidate’s conviction history.

While Ban the Box removes questions from the initial job application, it doesn’t prohibit background checks, it simply dictates when they can occur, usually post-conditional job offer.

Understanding the nuances of employment law in each jurisdiction is critical for compliance.

Process Adjustments

Organizations must adapt their hiring workflows to remain compliant with Ban the Box mandates.

This includes updating employment applications, training hiring managers on compliant interview questions, and aligning adverse action protocols to ensure decisions are legally sound.

Every step — from application to employment decision — should be documented and consistently applied.

Risk Management

Though Ban the Box changes the timeline, it does not eliminate the need for background checks or the role of a background screener.

Employers should conduct individualized assessments and weigh the relevance of criminal offenses to the role before taking any adverse action.

A documented, fair process helps protect companies from liability and supports a safer work environment.

How Staffing Agencies Play a Critical Role

Guiding Employers Through Compliance

Staffing agencies are well-positioned to help employers navigate the complexities of Ban the Box compliance, especially when operating across multiple states.

Agencies act as a trusted support service, advising on legal updates, helping avoid penalties, and ensuring that all hiring materials and interviews meet regulatory standards.

Skill-First Candidate Evaluation

One of the core strengths of a reputable employment agency is the ability to focus on skills and experience over background.

This skill-first approach aligns naturally with Fair Chance Laws, allowing agencies to identify the best talent for each role without initial bias tied to criminal records.

Improving Candidate Experience

Employment opportunities are more accessible when the application process is respectful and transparent.

Staffing firms play a key role in setting expectations with candidates around background check timing, conditional offers, and what information may be requested later.

This transparency builds trust and improves candidate retention.

Supporting Fair-Chance Talent Pipelines

Leading staffing firms are investing in relationships with community organizations and workforce development programs to create pipelines for fair-chance talent.

By connecting employers with job seekers who are ready and capable, they help place individuals into roles suited to their skills and experience — benefiting both parties and reducing recidivism.

Best Practices for Implementing Ban the Box in Staffing & Hiring

Employers and staffing agencies should follow key practices to align with Fair Chance Act standards and avoid legal missteps:

Clearly document which roles require a background check and the job-related reasons for doing so.
Delay background checks until after a conditional job offer is extended.
Establish individualized assessment processes to determine whether a criminal offense is relevant to the role.
Train all hiring stakeholders on methods to reduce bias and employment discrimination, as well as partnering with HR on adverse action matters.
Avoid using AI-powered systems in ways that may lead to discriminatory screening outcomes.
Ensure compliance with civil rights laws and avoid inquiries into medical examination results unless legally permissible.

The Future of Ban-the-Box and Fair-Chance Hiring

As workplace values evolve, so too does the demand for equitable hiring practices.

Organizations that embrace Ban the Box and other fair-chance principles will be better positioned to tap into a broader, more diverse pool of talent.

Rather than viewing it as a compliance challenge, employers should see Ban the Box as an opportunity to rethink how they define and evaluate talent.

By expanding access to employment opportunities, employers can improve business outcomes, strengthen their workforce, and contribute to a more inclusive society.

In this way, Ban the Box is more than policy — it’s a reflection of progress in how we build the future of work.

Looking to hire top-tier Tech, Digital Marketing, or Creative Talent? We can help.

Every year, Mondo helps to fill thousands of open positions nationwide.

Hire Talent

More Reading…

By Sarah Magazzo

Digital Marketing Manager for Mondo National Staffing Agency | AI Drafted & Human Crafted

What “Ban the Box” Means for Staffing Agencies & Today’s Hiring Landscape

What Is “Ban the Box”?

Why Ban the Box Matters in the Current Job Market

Widening Talent Pools During Skill Shortages